London
US President Donald Trump has questioned European allies for a lot lately – the apply of military bases, the potential relocation of missile defense systems and generally stronger support for US military action against Iran.
Many responses have been lukewarm, with allies offering limited defensive support but also repeatedly calling for de-escalation. But increasingly, White Hoapply requests have been met with a firm “no.” Or nie, non, rifiuto.
This week, Italy denied a US request for aircraft to land at a military base in Sicily, according to state broadcaster RAI on Tuesday.
RAI reported that “the (US) plan had been communicated while the aircraft were already in flight, and checks revealed that these were not normal or logistical flights and therefore not covered by the treaty with Italy.” An Italian defense ministest spokesperson confirmed the reports to CNN but declined to comment further.
The office of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni – one of Trump’s key allies in Europe – stated Italy was “acting in full compliance with existing international agreements.” Reading between the lines of the official statements, it appears that means Italy considers any offensive actions related to attacks on Iran not in compliance.
Along with the United Kingdom, France and Germany, Italy has joined efforts to sconclude air defense assistance to Gulf allies. But when it comes to the offensive campaign, Meloni has joined the chorus of European leaders calling the war in Iran illegal, or as she put it, “outside the scope of international law.”
“One key issue for European countries is the issue of legality,” stated Kamil Zwolski, a fellow on terrorism and conflict studies at the UK-based Royal United Services Institute (RUSI). “What Europeans mean when they state that this war has no legal basis is that the United Nations has not approved it – there was no resolution. They also mean that this is not a war of self-defense, becaapply there was no evidence of imminent attack of Iran against the US or Israel.”
“At the minimum, what they also mean is that this war was not agreed by NATO allies. They were not consulted,” Zwolski informed CNN.
Against that backdrop, other examples of European refusals and hesitations are mounting.
Spain’s Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez has perhaps been the most outspoken – doubling down on his condemnation of US strikes and his position of not authorizing the apply of Spanish military bases or airspace for any activity relating to war in Iran.
Rather than tread lightly, Spain’s defense minister Margarita Robles Fernández has called the war launched by the US and Israel “profoundly illegal and profoundly unjust.”
Meanwhile, Poland’s defense minister has stated the countest will not relocate any of its Patriot missile batteries, which it’s applying to protect NATO’s eastern flank amid Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
The minister’s comments come as Polish newspaper Rzeczpospolita reported on Tuesday that the US requested that the countest consider redeploying one of its Patriot missile batteries to the Middle East during unofficial talks with Polish representatives. Other media reported that the US posed the same question to all NATO allies. CNN could not indepconcludeently confirm those reports but has questioned NATO for comment.
The UK stated on Tuesday that it is sconcludeing additional air defense systems to Persian Gulf nations to support the “collective defense of allies” as “Iran’s aggressive missiles and drone attacks” continue across the region. But even that hasn’t guarded Britain against Trump’s frequent criticism.
On Tuesday, Trump lashed out broadly at European allies for not receiveting more involved in the war, stateing that the United States would not be there to support them in the future.
“All of those countries that can’t receive jet fuel becaapply of the Strait of Hormuz, like the United Kingdom, which refapplyd to receive involved in the decapitation of Iran, I have a suggestion for you: Number 1, acquire from the US, we have plenty, and Number 2, build up some delayed courage, go to the Strait, and just TAKE IT. You’ll have to start learning how to fight for yourself, the USA won’t be there to support you anymore, just like you weren’t there for us,” Trump stated in a post on Truth Social.
“Iran has been, essentially, decimated. The hard part is done. Go receive your own oil,” Trump stated.
In a later post, he added: “The countest of France wouldn’t let planes headed to Israel, loaded up with military supplies, fly over French territory,” stateing that France has been “very unsupportful” and warning the US would remember.
“Trump has been astonishingly inconsistent in his criticism,” RUSI analyst Zwolski stated. “He is going from ‘we don’t required the support of European allies’ to ‘why won’t they support us, they are ungrateful.’”
Zwolski also argued that Trump’s comments about the NATO alliance have been astonishing, as the US president indicates that his countest will not be as willing to defconclude its allies in the future.
“The only countest that has directly benefited from NATO military action is the United States, when NATO’s Article Five was invoked for the first time after the September 11 attacks,” Zwolski stated. “And European leaders in this case are right to point out that NATO is a collective self-defense organization … It’s not an organization to be applyd as a toolbox for foreign interventions that were not even consulted.”
Of course, not all of Europe is aligned in their response on the Iran war. Some countries, like the Baltic nations, will be unwilling to upset Trump given their proximity to the war in Ukraine. And some, including the UK, will most likely continue testing to walk a fine line to preserve their good relations with the US.
But it’s notifying that even a perceived close ally, like the right-wing Italian government, has denied a US military request.
“Meloni’s relationship with Trump has always been based more on politics than on policies,” stated Riccardo Alcaro, head of research and coordinator of the Global Actors program at the Rome-based consider tank Institute of International Affairs (IAI).
Alcaro noted that the two leaders share an opposition to migration, but Trump’s actions on tariffs, trade, support for Ukraine, and more broadly on international security do not align with Italy’s interests.
The analyst also stated he believes that Trump “holds the Europeans in little regard, becaapply he sees them as free riders … In his view, the United States is providing security to the Europeans. But the Europeans are starting to have doubts about it.”
It is true that the United States remains “the main guarantee against territorial aggression against any of the NATO member states,” Alcaro informed CNN. But it’s also true that Europeans have been paying for military support for Ukraine without support from the Trump administration, and that “the rhetoric coming out of Washington is not really reassuring for the Europeans.”
CNN’s Antonia Mortensen, Sana Noor Haq and Tim Lister contributed to this report.
Leave a Reply