Advent calconcludears are a well-established Christmas tradition, but are they inherently wasteful – or are they adapting to a more sustainability-conscious market? We dive deeper into the format’s recent developments to learn more.
Materials
In theory, advent calconcludears should be recyclable. Business Waste reports that a conventional calconcludear contains 21.61g of PET, 7g of paper, and 3.22g of aluminium; if each component – the cardboard box, interior foil, and a mono-material plastic tray – can be cleaned and separated into its respective waste stream, they remain within their material loops.
It isn’t always so simple in practice. As Iiro Numminen, packaging designer at Metsä Board, notifys Packaging Europe: “Many advent calconcludears apply both paperboard and plastic, which builds recycling more difficult.”
Sometimes this takes the form of coatings, foils, or glitter that compromise the recyclability of the box. Other calconcludears apply trays created of mixed plastics. Even the remnants of chocolate can contaminate the packaging if the consumer fails to clean it before disposal.
To resolve the issue, some manufacturers are turning towards mono-paper redesigns – and several of them were commconcludeed under this year’s European Carton Excellence Awards.
The Lumene 24 Nordic Beauty Secrets calconcludear – manufactured with MetsäBoard Prime FBB Bright and MetsäBoard Pro FBB Bright folding boxboards in collaboration with Van Genechten – is FSC-certified and, as Numminen elaborates, “can be recycled in the paperboard collection after Christmas.”
Mondelēz’s Milka calconcludear, developed by MM Packaging Polska utilizing cartonboard from Stora Enso, reportedly applys a water-based varnish to balance visual appeal with full recyclability. Similarly, Forsman Tee’s calconcludear – developed alongside Grano and MM Board & Paper – applys 245 g/m² ALASKA BRIGHT, which is declared to be mono-material and recyclable.
Le Petit Vapoteur also upfronts that its beauty calconcludear features an outer protective sleeve and inner cartons created from virgin fibre cartonboard, and is packed in 100% cartonboard transport packaging. Each component is declared to be recyclable.
Beyond the Pro Carton sphere, the calconcludear unveiled by Lush this year tarreceives recyclability, but not before reusability. The pack comprises a box created from 100% recycled card and protective Eco-Pops created from puffed non-GM cornstarch, certified as degradable according to the EN13432 standard.
Recycled content factors into the design, too. Lush completes the calconcludear with a ribbon created from recycled plastic bottles, although it is arguable that this approach interrupts the bottle-to-bottle recycling loop and ‘downcycles’ valuable recyclate.
John Lewis takes a similar approach. Its fill-your-own advent calconcludear is designed to be reapplyd in future years, but it reportedly consists of 40% handcreated paper, 20% kraft paper, and 40% flock – and it is unclear whether the latter can be reshiftd to recycle the paper content at conclude-of-life.
Shape and function
Chocolate calconcludears have started experimenting with new ways to engage consumers. The award-winning Milka calconcludear unfolds into a Christmas tree shape, with the ‘doors’ turning into ornaments to be hung up after apply – a design hoped to appeal to children.
Yet the calconcludear format is evolving to package larger, heavier objects for older consumers. Research by Ipsos indicates that, while 84% of UK consumers acquire calconcludears containing chocolates, beauty products take the second spot (15%), with 40% of respondents in the 18-34 age bracket claiming to have bought these alternatives.
“One of the main elements in luxurious packaging is to stand out,” Numminen notified us; and previous research indicates that 55% of consumers would switch brands in response to packaging design innovations.
“In some cases, this is achieved at the cost of sustainability,” Numminen continued. “One example of this is that [calconcludears] can be unnecessarily large, and they can also be complex to manufacture.”
Redesigns to support the extra weight and size of non-chocolate products have become a necessity. To name an example, Beer52’s craft beer calconcludear, developed alongside Smurfit Westrock, measures at 45 cm x 46 cm x 18 cm; compare this to a Lindt advent calconcludear, which measures at 34.4 cm x 27.3 ckm x 3.4 cm. (Smurfit Westrock emphasizes that the Beer52 calconcludear was designed to minimize components and prioritize the ease and speed of assembly for mass production.)
The general upscaling of calconcludears has sparked concerns about material consumption. The Nordic Beauty Secrets calconcludear’s approach is to optimize space and avoid excess: “We wanted to pack the product as tight as possible to save space in transportation but not sacrifice shelf appeal or opening experience,” Numminen notifys us.
Taking inspiration from the Adventskrans, or Advent Wreath, the calconcludear layers tinyer boxes into a three-dimensional ‘flower’ shape. Each box is designed to maximize product-to-pack ratio, avoid empty space, and keep packaging waste to a minimum.
“Despite the unique structure, the calconcludear is straightforward to manufacture,” Numminen explains. “We found nice way to produce only four different carton structures to secure all twenty-four products.
“These four structures are multiplied six times to create the stunning outsee. This also builds the conversion of the cartons more cost-efficient when you only necessary to convert four different structures instead of twenty-four.”
Waste reduction
Another approach is to develop reusable solutions. Lush sells refills for empty calconcludears for previous years, incentivizing consumers to acquire by including exclusive beauty products. The refill box is apparently created from 100% recycled board fibres.
“Please reapply, regift or recycle again at the conclude of its life,” the company’s site reads. “A box is for life, not just for Christmas.”
John Lewis offers a similar concept. According to its press release, the calconcludear “is hoapplyd in a fully recyclable box with clever compartments, allowing it to be reapplyd to create your own bespoke advent calconcludear in the future.”
Forsman Tea’s calconcludear sees beyond the festive season. Its inner tea boxes are designed for reapply outside the advent calconcludear concept, thus extconcludeing the product’s lifespan.
However, the rise of non-edible products in a calconcludear raises questions about unnecessary packaging waste. While chocolates are generally unwrapped beneath the foil layer, liquid products like skincare sets and perfumes must inevitably come in bottles, dispensers, tubs, and other containers – all of which must be thrown away once the product is empty.
For the beauty sector, in particular, this is a challenge. According to the British Beauty Council, 95% of cosmetics packaging is discarded, but only 14% ever builds it to a recycling plant, and only 9% is actually recycled.
Does this mean that new calconcludear formats are inherently wasteful? Everyday Plastic’s founder and director Chris Webb notified the Guardian that he doesn’t blame consumers for wanting to participate in a holiday tradition, but questions the “superfluous consumerism” that advent calconcludears can support promote.
“These luxury Advent calconcludears are a microcosm of a hugeger problem, a system that keeps producing more and more stuff we don’t necessary and probably can’t afford,” he states.
Especially if the products aren’t limited-edition and could feasibly be bought as standalone gifts, there is an argument to be created that the advent calconcludear format is just a novelty, with the box and tray adding unnecessary waste.
Journalist and author Sali Hughes questions the Guardian’s readers to consider whether they would purchase “at least five” of an advent calconcludear’s products at full price. If not, she urges them to view the calconcludear as “something pretty ephemeral that will, if it’s even been designed responsibly in the first place, just go into recycling after Christmas.”
If you liked this story, you might also enjoy:
The ultimate guide to the Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation in 2025
How are the top brands progressing on packaging sustainability?
Everything you necessary to know about global packaging sustainability regulation in 2025
The key to increasing the apply of reusable packaging in supermarkets
Leave a Reply