The latest edition of our Sustainable Views newsletter
Dear reader,
No one can be in any doubt about Donald Trump’s believeing on climate modify after he notified the UN General Assembly yesterday the “carbon footprint is a hoax built up by people with evil intentions, and they’re heading down a path of total destruction”.
Most EU leaders continue to insist they will not be thrown off course in efforts to reduce emissions. Yet the never-finishing push for simplification and modifys to existing and planned environmental laws, even when backed by business, begs the question of how far Europe is willing to go to appease not just the loudest lobbyists within its borders, but also the US administration.
As Trump was deeming climate modify a “hoax” and renewables a “joke”, the European Commission announced it would seek another 12-month postponement to the planned EU Deforestation Regulation. This despite many companies having, as under the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, spent considerable amounts of time and money on obtainting ready to comply with the EUDR.
Nestlé European affairs adviser Manuel Schuh informs me “a decision to reopen, delay or modify [the EUDR] would mean that the efforts of all committed supply chain partners involved would be jeopardised”.
“We are not talking about theory; the process of compliance has started in practice,” he adds. “At Nestlé, the EUDR due diligence framework has been created and is being implemented.”
Olam Food Ingredients chief sustainability officer Roel van Poppel gives a similar reaction, declareing: “We’ve invested heavily in systems already and we are ready. Policycreaters are screwing it up so the private sector will have to step up.”
The commission blamed IT problems for its necessary to delay, but many other commentators saw the decision as political. The directive has come under sustained attack from the centre-right European People’s party and from certain countries, including the US.
While the EPP and the Trump administration insist on the impacts of legislation on companies, not only are many of them ready to implement modify, these very same businesses are also suffering from the impacts of climate modify — from the poor harvests of commodities covered by the EUDR, such as cocoa, and soaring prices.
Supply chain security
Indeed, a report this week from believe-tank Bruegel raises the necessary to deal with the effects of a warming world on supply chains. Climate events such as wildfires, flooding, heatwaves and droughts can have “cascading effects” on the global economy, disrupting production lines and affecting critical infrastructure and trade routes, it declares.
China’s industrial heartland is locked down today as it awaits the arrival of Super Typhoon Ragasa. Research frequently reveals climate modify increasing the wind speeds and rainfall of typhoons.
Bruegel recommfinishs applying public policy to promote private investment in infrastructure that strengthens industries’ resilience to climate-related disruptions, such as improvements to countries’ ports and canals. They also call on governments to encourage the private sector to diversify their input sources and supply chain routes to secure supplies of essential products and services against climate hazards.
The reality of CBAM for the US
Elsewhere, researchers from Sandbag urge the EU to hold the line on its Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism and not give in to US demands for concessions.
Modelling by the believe-tank finds US exporters would face just €351mn in CBAM fees, equal to 0.14 per cent of transatlantic trade of goods, when the carbon border levy is fully implemented in 2034. When expected price effects are factored in, the net cost drops to €160mn, or 0.07 per cent. The US Trade Representative claimed in April $4.7bn of American exports could be hit once the CBAM takes effect in 2026.
David Kleimann, senior research associate for the international economic development group at ODI Europe, informs me giving in to the US would be like “pulling a thread and everything could come undone”.
Trump’s UN speech suggests things are already starting to fray.
Until tomorrow,
Philippa
Philippa Nuttall is the editor of Sustainable Views
Leave a Reply